No matter how old we are, we all scream for ice cream! From old fashioned ice cream shops to modern local artisanal creameries, you will find the best ice cream shops on Long Island right here! These Long Island ice cream establishments have received excellent reviews internet-wide and are specially ranked by our unique algorithm. If you are wondering where to find fresh homemade butter pecan ice cream with all the toppings you can imagine, we’ve got them all! You may find that your new favorite ice cream shop in your neighborhood is just around the corner. So forget the calories, go back to your childhood, and enjoy all the delectable heaven a sugar cone can hold!